When the dashing Eric Reynolds (Henry Mollison) stands her up at the altar, distraught socialite Sheila Curtis (Anne Nagel) turns to her lawyer and friend Henry Tuttle (Warren Hull) to make everything all right. Henry agrees to marry her, hoping she'll learn to love him, but he doesn't count on his new bride to still nurse feelings for the man who broke her heart. Will Sheila's plan to win Eric back turn out for better … or for worse?