Guest star Tina Fey and her Bookaneers drop anchor at Sesame Street and they're hoping to raid Elmo's bookshelf. After the lovable red monster discovers their plan and finds out how much these pirates love to read, he begs to join the crew. But before he can become a Bookaneer, Elmo must help them hunt for hidden treasure. This Sesame Street production also includes a claymation short that has Bert and Ernie searching for a cache of loot.