The serenity of a rural Pennsylvania community is shattered when a young Amish girl, Katie (Alison Pill), is accused of killing her newborn baby. High-powered, big-city criminal attorney Ellie Harrison (Mariska Hargitay) steps in to defend the teen suspect, but her case is hindered by Katie's insistence that she was never pregnant. Can Ellie uncover the truth in this fiercely private society that distrusts outsiders?