Nerdy teacher Ronald Gibb (Tim Daly) has trouble hiding his tiny crush on gorgeous student Ally (Hayden Panettiere), which all starts to look very bad for Ronald once Ally is kidnapped and he's the last person to be seen with her. As Ronald becomes the main suspect, the suburban community turns upside down in this dark comedy, also starring William Sadler as Ally's entrepreneurial father and Sarah Steele as the spunky Amber Jinxs.