Twenty years ago, the coastal town of Devil's Lake was the target of a bizarre string of brutal murders by the "Keyhole Killer," and as suddenly as the slayings began, they stopped. Now, it's happening again: The killer has returned to finish what he started. Haunted by the memory of his murdered parents who were among the original victims, Deputy Jake Barker (Justin Ament) is determined to unmask the butcher behind the bloodshed.