Nihilistic slacker Tre (Daniel Cariaga) begins an affair with Nina (Alix Koromzay), who recently caught her husband kissing another woman. Witnessing Nina's indiscretion, her friend Kakela (Kimberly-Rose Wolter) begins to question her own relationship with her fiancé. It's Tre who suggests an experiment to test her love, but the result may destroy them all. Eric Byler co-wrote and directed this sequel to his award-winning Charlotte Sometimes.