Everyone's favorite characters from the hit Nickelodeon series are thrown into a conundrum when Freddie (Nathan Kress) pushes Carly (Miranda Cosgrove) out of the path of a careening taco truck, forcing Carly to re-examine her feelings for him in the title tale of this collection. In other episodes, Carly and Sam (Jennette McCurdy) squabble over some local talent, Sam 'fesses up to kissing Freddie, and Carly tutors her brother's nemesis.