Tingley is a trained vocalist, and her varied résumé includes a singing role in the short film Light as a Feather (2010). She also appeared in the Australian miniseries Cloudstreet and learned sign language to portray a deaf girl in the short film Beneath the Waves (both 2011).
In 2012, Tingley was cast in the Netflix original horror series "Hemlock Grove," playing a budding novelist who jumps at the chance to interview a murder suspect.
Adapted from the hit Broadway musical, this nostalgic look at the Four Seasons and their bumpy offstage lives stretches across four decades. Each of the musical act's four original members presents a different set of memories from their shared past.